The AFL State of Origin is back, and it’s already sparking a debate that could reshape the sport’s calendar. But here’s where it gets controversial: after Victoria’s thrilling 24-point victory over Western Australia, coaches Chris Scott and Dean Cox are boldly calling for the event to become an annual tradition—a move that’s dividing fans and experts alike. Could this be the future of AFL, or is it a one-time wonder? Let’s dive in.
On Saturday night, a sold-out Perth Stadium roared with energy as 58,141 fans witnessed a hard-fought battle, with Victoria clinching the win 18.17 (125) to 15.11 (101). Western Australia mounted a fierce comeback in the final quarter, narrowing the gap to just six points thanks to Jesse Hogan’s three quick goals. But Victoria’s star-studded lineup held their ground, securing the first AFL Origin victory since 1999. And this is the part most people miss: the sheer passion and effort from both teams have reignited calls for State of Origin to become a permanent fixture.
Chris Scott, Victoria’s winning coach, couldn’t hide his enthusiasm. “I would love nothing more than to see this grow,” he said. “I’m a huge advocate, and I think this has the potential to be something massive. There’s no reason it shouldn’t happen every year.” Scott even suggested that if player interest ever wanes, adjustments could be made—though he doubts that’ll happen. “I think it will only gain momentum. As a coach, I’d rather have my players here than in a pre-season practice match,” he added, drawing a clear comparison to less exciting alternatives.
Dean Cox, Western Australia’s coach, echoed Scott’s sentiments. “State of Origin should be every year,” he declared. “Whether it’s a carnival or a standalone game, the AFL needs to figure out how to make it happen.” Cox praised the WA government, tourism board, and fans for their unwavering support, suggesting Perth deserves to host it again. “If you’re a player from South Australia or the Allies, you’d be wondering why you weren’t part of this,” Scott added, hinting at the broader appeal of the concept.
What’s truly remarkable is the players’ buy-in. Not a single eligible AFL star turned down the chance to represent their state. Even a string of injuries—including Carlton’s Jacob Weitering being hospitalized with potential neck, rib, and shoulder damage—didn’t dampen the enthusiasm. Other players, like Callum Ah Chee, Mitch Georgiades, Sam Taylor, and Matt Rowell, faced hamstring and finger injuries, yet the excitement remained palpable.
Jesse Hogan summed it up perfectly: “This year was a bit of the unknown, but as the teams were announced, the excitement grew. Everyone who played underage footy or dreams of representing their state could see this blossoming into something special. There’s no reason players wouldn’t want to be part of this every year.”
But here’s the burning question: Can State of Origin sustain its momentum, or will it fizzle out like past attempts? Scott believes WA has the “front running” to host it again, but other states are already clamoring for their chance. And while the concept has undeniable appeal, balancing it with the AFL’s packed schedule won’t be easy.
Controversial take: What if State of Origin becomes so popular it overshadows traditional club rivalries? Could it dilute the focus on the AFL season, or will it inject new life into the sport? Weigh in below—do you think State of Origin should be an annual event, or is once every two decades enough? Let the debate begin!
